"A New York Treasure" --Village Voice

…If We Don't We're Gonna Blow a 50-Amp Fuse

Steven Goldman’s latest take on Brian Cashman and the Yankees’ off-season:

On one hand, Cashman’s nerves are understandable. He has a reliable ace in CC Sabathia and then four question marks. However, you would think he would be excited about what a great opportunity the team has to get better and save money at the same time. As I’ve said throughout the offseason, the Yankees have so many near-ready pitching prospects that at least one of them should pay off. It’s entirely possible they go 0-for-8 or so in young starters in 2011, but it seems unlikely, especially given how talented some of these kids are. While only one of them seems to have true ace potential at this writing (young Mr. Betances), somewhere on this year’s Scranton or Trenton rosters lurks a pitcher or two who can fill out the back of a rotation better than Dustin Moseley or Sergio Mitre can, and that’s all the Yankees really need if their offense and defense are up to last year’s standards. What should be even better from Cashman’s point of view is not only can these tyro hurlers be good, they won’t be arbitration eligible for two or three years.

If all of Cashman’s fears are justified, then 2011 turns out to be a transition year as the Yankees break in their new rotation. Yes, the results-only crowd, which tends to include Yankees ownership, would consider that a disappointment. The problem is, as the Pavano-Wright epoch demonstrates, you can’t force these things. Even Cliff Lee by himself wouldn’t have made 2011 any more of a sure thing, though he would have reduced the number of gambles the Yankees would have to undertake. Penciling Freddy Garcia and his 4.50-5.00 ERA into the rotation won’t change a thing except to lower the team’s profit margins. If the Yankees want to take an injury-prone, low-strikeout fly-ball pitcher and stick him in Yankee Stadium and have him shell the Bleacher Creatures, that’s their right, but it isn’t smart and it isn’t better than letting a kid do the same thing, because the kid is cheaper and might actually get better.

Categories:  Bronx Banter  Hot Stove  Yankees

Tags:  Brian Cashman  Steven Goldman

Share: Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email %PRINT_TEXT


1 Chyll Will   ~  Dec 21, 2010 2:04 pm

Does asking for charts on Freddy Garcia automatically mean the Yanks signed him? Why is it when other teams do that, it just means they're checking his medical records?

Tune in tomorrow for the continuation of Cashman Shrugged only on Bronx Banter...

2 Jon DeRosa   ~  Dec 21, 2010 2:06 pm

Oh, I hope Andy retires. What joy it will be to see the Yankees use 2/5 of their rotation for the foreseeable future on a revolving door of minor leaguers. Their small sample evaluations, pitch limits, and youthful innocence will be a welcome escape while Boston and Tampa busy themselves with the excruciatingly dull chase of championships.

3 Mattpat11   ~  Dec 21, 2010 2:40 pm

However, you would think he would be excited about what a great opportunity the team has to get better and save money at the same time

It went about as poorly as imaginable last time. I can see that affecting Cashman's excitement.

4 MDF   ~  Dec 21, 2010 3:03 pm

I think Goldman is saving up for box seats for the 2015 series.

feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email
"This ain't football. We do this every day."
--Earl Weaver