
If we’re to believe Professors Hershiser, Morgan, and Miller, this was a successful weekend for the Boston Red Sox. Or it was a successful weekend for the New York Yankees. By only splitting the four-game season in the Bronx, the Sox leave town with the same six-game deficit they brought with them, and since the Rays have been scuffling as well, the Yankees are still two games up in the division — never a bad thing.
The disappointing thing, though, is that this game could easily have gone the other way. Phil Hughes had a bit of trouble in the second inning, giving up two runs on a handful of stolen bases and infield singles, but then recovered nicely. Aside from a two-out double in the fifth surrendered to Victor Martínez, Hughes was perfect the rest of the way. He fell victim to his high pitch count and left after six innings, but Kerry Wood, Boone Logan, and Joba Chamberlain held down the Sox hitters over the final three innings, giving the Yankees three different chances to win in the later innings.
Jon Lester was almost unhittable for most of the afternoon, not faltering until the seventh inning when Jorge Posada opened the frame with a ground ball single to left field. Marcus Thames came up next and smoked a rocket towards the bullpen in right center field. The game hung in the balance for just as long as it took the ball to fly from Thames’s bat to the very tip of the wall. Another inch — seriously — and it would’ve scraped over the wall, tying the game at two, but the fence held the ball in, gently dropping it onto the warning track in front of Jacoby Ellsbury. On the radio broadcast John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman went on and on about the terrible bit of bad luck that had just kept the Yanks from evening the score, but it’s not like they were in bad shape with men on second and third and no one out. Five pitchers later things looked even better as Lester plunked Austin Kearns to load the bases. With Curtis Granderson, Derek Jeter, and Nick Swisher lying in wait, the game would surely be tied at the very least.
But it didn’t happen that way. Lester muscled up to strike out Granderson and was relieved by flame thrower Daniel Bard who dismissed Jeter and Swisher on six high octane fastballs. Threat over.
Mark Teixeira led off the eighth with big home run off of the same Mr. Bard who had been unhittable only moments earlier, and when Alex Rodríguez followed that with a single, things were suddenly interesting again. But then Mr. Girardi entered the fray. Now, even though I was a bit critical of his performance in Sunday night’s game, I don’t usually criticize Girardi — or any other manager, for that matter. But there’s one habit Girardi has that drives me absolutely crazy. He loves to pinch run, and it doesn’t matter a bit who’s coming out of the game. So when A-Rod, singled and reached base as the potential tying run, Girardi pulled him in favor of Brett Gardner. First of all, I love Brett Gardner. Love him. And I understand that he’s a walking stolen base, but I have two huge problems with Girardi’s line of thinking. First, by running Gardner, you’re essentially playing for a tie. This is fine, except that you’ve just removed one of your best hitters, a hitter who otherwise might’ve helped you win the game when his spot comes around again. Second, it’s not like you’re running for Jorge Posada; A-Rod can steal a bag. Gardner then added to my frustration by staying anchored to first for the first five pitches of Robinson Canó’s at bat. He finally ran as Canó grounded out to second, putting him in scoring position, but if you’re going to pinch run Gardner in that spot, shouldn’t you send him to first base with explicit directions to run early in the count so that Canó, Posada, and Thames would each have an opportunity to drive in the tying run? But what do I know?
Now back to the actual game. After Posada walked, Lance Berkman hit for Thames and popped out to left for the second out, then Jonathan Papelbon came on to retire Austin Kearns on one pitch. Another threat over.
True to form, the Yankees mustered one final rally in the ninth inning when Jeter walked with one out and stole second, but Papelbon wrapped it up by striking out Swisher and Teixeira. Red Sox 2, Yankees 1.