"A New York Treasure" --Village Voice

The Good Stuff is in the Middle

gray

Alex Witchel wrote a terrific piece on the Irish novelist Colm Toibin last weekend in the New York Times Magazine. I have not read anything by Toibin but this caught my attention:

It is Toibin’s triumph as a writer that his sympathy for his devils — especially the mothers — is great enough to spread the blame to everyone around them. For him, contradictions are paramount. The unexpected rush of warm feeling he can unleash for a character toward whom you have hardened your heart is one of those luxurious moments of catharsis you rarely experience in real life.

…“Do you know it has no single words for yes and no [in Gaelic]?” he said to Sam, animatedly. The fact of it delighted him. For someone who has such little use for “good” and “bad,” the very notions of “yes” and “no” are equally prosaic. Why bother with such useless extremes when all the really good stuff is in the middle?

I find myself looking for nice, pat answers too often, looking at the world in black-and-white terms, as a moralist. I don’t like feeling uncomfortable so I look for easy answers to complicated issues. I know this is foolish.  Or I know it speaks to my own insecurities and that all of the really good, complicated, messy stuff is in the middle.

Here is an except from Toibin’s latest novel, Brooklyn.

Share: Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email %PRINT_TEXT

3 comments

1 Diane Firstman   ~  May 8, 2009 11:11 am

Nice post AB!

Complicated issues .... like PEDs in baseball? Not an earth-shaking do-or-die issue ... but one that makes my sports-loving head hurt.

2 jonnystrongleg   ~  May 8, 2009 11:55 am

Thanks Alex, this was a welcome perspective given the atmosphere in the Banter community these days.

I wonder where we're headed with these complicated PED issues. I encourage anybody who has a strong, or strongly divided, opinion on the PED debate to read this recent New Yorker article on neuro enhancers:

http://tinyurl.com/cm4b75

It makes me think that this perioud of steroid related upheval will be viewed as quaint and harmless given where we might end up as a society.

3 Ben   ~  May 8, 2009 12:06 pm

Yeah!
Between the predictive numbers and routine plays and all that we can cement, that's where the real game of baseball is played. Between the lines.

I don't even mind it when the Yanks lose. The ball rolls funny for everyone. But I hate it when the real stuff, the feel, the approach, the passion, is lacking. Cano looked awful in the at-bat I saw last night. Whereas My wife and I both called Damon's shot. You could just FEEL it. More Damon, less Cano and I'm a happy fan, win or lose.

feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email
"This ain't football. We do this every day."
--Earl Weaver