The last two weeks have been difficult for our Yankees, and that’s largely because of injuries and inconsistencies. (But if we’re being honest, some of the most consistent players recently have been those who have been consistently bad. More on that later.)
Consider all this…
Ben Rice, the hottest hitter on the roster, missed a handful of games with an injury I’ve never seen in the fifty years I’ve been watching baseball — he bruised his hand while catching a throw at first base.
José Caballero, who’s been a pleasant surprise even if he’s been caught stealing more times than we might like, was placed on the ten-day injured list against his wishes.
Max Fried left a start with elbow soreness, shaking all of Yankees Universe to its core with fears of losing another ace to Tommy John surgery. With Gerrit Cole due back on Friday, the internet was rife with theories that some type of curse was preventing Fried and Cole from being in the rotation at the same time. (Turns out it was just a bone bruise, but Fried will still miss at least a month.)
Anthony Volpe spent a few days in triple A purgatory after his rehab status expired, fueling the idea that this new ruthless Yankees front office means business this season, but Caballero’s injury open a space at shortstop, and Volpe returned. He hasn’t been impressive either in the field or at bat, so it will be interesting to see what happens when Caballero comes back on Friday.
Jasson Domínguez was playing well and even hitting some against lefties, and then he crashed into a wall making, of all things, an outstanding play in left field.
Spencer Jones finally made an appearance in the major leagues, and it looks like the Aaron Judge comparisons we’ve been hearing have been correct — only it’s 2017 Judge, not MVP Judge.
Trent Grisham has had a moment or two, and while there are some positive numbers, he’s still hitting well below .200 with a significant number of at bats, enough that he could be the most troubling batter in the lineup.
But if Grisham isn’t your biggest concern, there’s Austin Wells. I don’t think anyone expected him to hit like Jorgé Posada this year, but I’m fairly certain that 55-year-old Posada could hit like Wells this year.
Finally, as crazy as it is to say this about someone with sixteen home runs two thirds of the way through May, Aaron Judge hasn’t really looked like Aaron Judge at any point this season.
Oh, wait — there’s also the bullpen, which probably deserves a post of its own.
That’s an awful lot of doom and gloom, but the Yankees still have the second-best record in the mediocre American League, and there are probably more reasons to be optimistic than otherwise. Judge is the last person on the planet we should worry about, Jazz Chisholm has been hitting well, Ryan McMahon is still the best defensive third baseman we’ve seen in the Bronx in about a decade, Cam Schlittler is the front runner for the Cy Young Award, Carlos Rodón looked good the other night aside from his flukish wild pitch/jump throw combination that cost two runs, and Gerrit Cole is starting on Friday night against the Rays.
The baseball season is a rollercoaster, and there will surely be more dips and unexpected turns before we get to October. I wish I could tell you that I’ll remember that when things begin to look bleak, but I’m sure I won’t. For now, though — Let’s Go, Yankees!


Hey, everybody. Really sorry the shop's been closed, but we're back!
By the way, I'd be curious to know what people think about McMahon. I referenced this above, but I feel like his defense is so good -- and I've worried about third base defense for so long -- that I think his average would have to drop below .150 before I'd worry.
I’m not here every night these days, nor probably every week for that matter. So apologies if this has been covered, but I feel like Rice is hitting Mattingly-style dingers this past year. Obviously they don’t have similar builds or swings, but he’s got a quick bat and the homers get out of there in a hurry. Roping line drives.
Tino used to sky them. Giambis felt like a sluggers homers. Maybe a little Paul O, but they definitely feel more Donnie-esque.
Any thoughts, or am I just an old guy projecting?
I’m busy packing. First vacation in literally a year. Taking care of 90+ y.o. parents is a full time job.
A week in Vermont with old college friends.
[3] The Mattingly comparison is spot on. He looks like a hitter whose line drives sometimes find the seats, just like Donnie Baseball.