I decided to begin with the year 1990 for one reason: I believe this was the year that the perennially contending Yankees as we know them actually began, with the ouster of Steinbrenner and the functional head of the organization now being Gene Michael (Steinbrenner’s last official act as managing partner of the Yankees was to fire the current GM Harding Peterson in favor of Michael), the Yanks began the process of reinventing themselves into an organization that valued growing and developing players first, rather than simply being the highest bidder for the biggest star in the free agent market, or trading away developing prospects for tried-and-true veterans whom somehow either flopped or otherwise failed to live up to expectations. Michael’s method valued potential over past results, and that method yielded some genuine value in both prospects and veterans (signed or traded for) who became franchise mainstays.
But within this process, there had to be players who either didn’t fit into the plan long term for one reason or another; perhaps they didn’t make the cut and were either relegated to the minors or released or traded, perhaps they were at the tail end of their careers and were basically picking up another check before they bid the major leagues adieu. Or, in some cases, they started out with the Yanks but didn’t make it with them, so they went somewhere else and became All Stars, or at the very least fan faves with another team. Many will be surprised at who donned the famous pinstripes at one point or another in their careers. Many know of the players who got a second wind with the Yankees after their stars had dimmed elsewhere; Strawberry, Gooden, Cone, Boggs, Fielder, Justice and the like. But as we start with 1990 and make our way to last season, you’ll find names that would have never occurred to you unless someone (here!) brought them to your attention. You can tell me if it’s fair or not to include them as “honorable mentions” or “who dat’s”, but that’s what I hope will keep the discussion lively. Feel free to contribute any stories about mentioned players that you might find interesting.
I’m going to build a key here and hope that it sticks:
- Opening Day Starters: underline
- Also Played: #
- Regulars On Roster: blank
- Renowned From Other Teams: bold
- Unheralded Rookie/Prospect: *
- Unheralded Vet: italics
So, here we go:
- 59 Steve Adkins*
- 25 Greg Cadaret#
- 51 Chuck Cary
- 58 Dave Eiland
- 35 Lee Guetterman
- 61 John Habyan
- 40 Andy Hawkins
- 26 Jimmy Jones
- 42 Dave LaPoint
- 54 Tim Leary
- 56 Mark Leiter
- 41 Lance McCullers
- 28,69 Alan Mills*
- 55 Rich Monteleone
- 38 Clay Parker
- 34 Pascual Pérez
- 33 Eric Plunk#
- 19 Dave Righetti
- 43 Jeff Robinson#
- 22 Mike Witt
- 11 Rick Cerone
- 28 Brian Dorsett
- 53 Bob Geren
- 38 Matt Nokes
- 50 Oscar Azócar*
- 29 Jesse Barfield
- 27 Mel Hall
- 39 Roberto Kelly
- 31 Hensley Meulens
- 21 Deion Sanders
- 17 Claudell Washington
- 31 Dave Winfield
- 22 Luis Polonia#
- 45 Steve Balboni
- 24,21 Mike Blowers*
- 20 Álvaro Espinoza
- 12 Jim Leyritz
- 24 Kevin Maas
- 23 Don Mattingly
- 6 Steve Sax
- 2 Wayne Tolleson
- 18 Randy Velarde#
- 63 Jim Walewander
Of that list, I had a little trouble categorizing Bob Geren, Claudell Washington, Rich Monteleone, Oscar Azócar and Mike Blowers because they were known/heralded, but not great players. The last two in particular were part of a pre-Michaels youth movement that also had rookies Steve Adkins, Mark Leiter, Jim Leyritz, Kevin Maas and Alan Mills making their major league debuts in 1990. Of this group, Leyritz would remain as a fixture, Maas would become a fan favorite for a time (but never a productive cog in the the team’s ambitions as Leyritz would be), Mills would star in Baltimore (but was often foiled by his former team), and Leiter went onto greater things with Detroit among other teams. Hensley Meulens was very much heralded and made his debut in 1985, but by 1990 was pretty much a permanent shuttle inhabitant between Columbus and the Bronx. But he did become a fixture and hero of The Netherlands in the World Baseball Classic, and he almost became the Yankees’ new manager recently, so there’s that.
Deion Sanders obviously has to be the name that jumps out the most, but he was well known for being a two-sport star; at the time playing for the Atlanta Falcons. If he had not struggled in his first two seasons with the Yanks and had Bo Jackson not suffered the injury that effectively ended his sports career, not to mention his “Prime Time” persona that rubbed quite a few baseball people the wrong way, Deion might have had a longer career with the Yanks. However, Stick released him after an unproductive second season and contentious contract extension talks, saying that football was stunting his growth as a baseball player. Perhaps this stung Deion in some way, or maybe the ease of being in the same city for both professions helped; when he signed with the Atlanta Braves, he suddenly became Bo Jackson Lite and was an immediate contributor to the teams that won two NL pennants in 1991-92. Consider it one of Michael’s few missteps.
This was also Dave Winfield’s last season with the Yanks, before he was traded in mid-May for pitcher Mike Witt. We all know the story with Winfield, which led to George’s ouster, but Witt was formerly a solid, if not ace-quality pitcher with the California Angels until he suddenly lost his mojo, and after the trade it never came back, with Witt mercifully disappearing from baseball after little more than two seasons and a plethora of injuries.
- October 1989: Dickie Noles was released by the Yankees.
- October 4, 1989: Steve Kiefer was released by the Yankees.
- November 20, 1989: Rafael Santana was released by the Yankees.
- November 21, 1989: Pascual Pérez was signed as a free agent by the Yankees.
- December 12, 1989: Hal Morris and Rodney Imes (minors) were traded by the Yankees to the Cincinnati Reds for Tim Leary and Van Snider.
- December 20, 1989: Rick Cerone was signed as a free agent by the Yankees.
- February 17, 1990: Mariano Rivera was signed as an amateur free agent by the Yankees.
- March 13, 1990: Orlando Miller was traded by the Yankees to the Houston Astros for Dave Silvestri and a player to be named later. The Astros completed the deal by sending Daven Bond (minors) to the Yankees on June 11.
- April 29, 1990: Luis Polonia was traded by the Yankees to the California Angels for Claudell Washington and Rich Monteleone.
- May 11, 1990: Dave Winfield was traded by the Yankees to the California Angels in exchange for Mike Witt.
- June 4, 1990: Clay Parker and Lance McCullers were traded by the Yankees to the Detroit Tigers for Matt Nokes.
- September 24, 1990: Deion Sanders was released by the Yankees.
June 4, 1990: 1990 Major League Baseball Draft
- Carl Everett was drafted by the Yankees in the 1st round.
- Robert Eenhoorn was drafted by the Yankees in the 2nd round of the 1990 June Draft. Player signed June 10, 1990.
- Sam Militello was drafted by the Yankees in the 6th round.
- Jalal Leach was drafted by the Yankees in the 7th round. Player signed June 8, 1990.
- Ricky Ledée was drafted by the Yankees in the 16th round. Player signed June 5, 1990.
- Andy Pettitte was drafted by the Yankees in the 22nd round, but did not sign.
- Jorge Posada was drafted by the Yankees in the 24th round. Player signed May 24, 1991.
- Shane Spencer was drafted by the Yankees in the 28th round. Player signed June 7, 1990.
Whoa, what a fun draft that was. There are quite a few others to talk about here, so look them up and ask away or talk about any that stand out beyond who or what I highlighted. Do you think the indications are fair? You tell me.