"A New York Treasure" --Village Voice

The Eternal Hope

If it’s true that hope springs eternal, we can agree that no hope springs as eternal as the hope of spring training.

Can it possibly be that the season starts this week? The biblical rains out here in Southern California have pushed the spring so far from my mind that I only just now realized that the vernal equinox has come and gone, so how can Opening Day be only four days away?

If you’ve been paying attention to the Yankees through February and March, you no doubt enjoyed the spring tease of Jasson Domínguez. With Harrison Bader set to begin the season on the injured list (more on that crowded room in a bit), there was part of me that hoped the Yankees would take a page from the Atlanta Braves’ book and just give the centerfield job to the young phenom, but I knew that would never happen. Sending the Martian back to the minors for another year of development was obviously the right move, but it wasn’t the exciting one.

Speaking of minor leaguers with potential, where do you come down on the Oswald Peraza vs. Anthony Volpe debate? After his successful September stint last season, most observers assumed that Peraza would emerge as the starting shortstop this spring, but then the Yankees let it slip that Volpe, the organization’s top prospect (and the #5 overall according to MLB Pipeline) would be part of a competition that would also include last year’s starter, Isaiah Kiner-Falefa.

Our friend IKF quickly became an afterthought — he’ll be on the roster, but likely as a super-utilityman — and the battle currently comes down to the 22-year-old Peraza and the 21-year-old Volpe. To call it a battle at this point, however, is a bit generous. Peraza has struggled while Volpe has starred, currently hitting .314 with a gaudy 1.064 OPS and five stolen bases over 51 spring training at bats.

If Volpe were 24 instead of 21, this wouldn’t even be a conversation, but some worry that pushing a prospect to the Bronx after only 89 AAA at bats could be a problem. Brendan Kuty and Chris Kirschner debate the competition in the Athletic and include this statement regarding the possible pitfalls of choosing Volpe over Peraza: “If Volpe fails early, the team will face ridicule for promoting him too soon.”

That seems ridiculous to me. There’s obviously no guarantee that Volpe will enjoy the same success in April and May as he has in March, but there’s also no reason not to give him the chance. I’m sorry that I’m about to be the thousandth person you know to point this out, but we’re talking about an organization that passed on a parade of all-star (and a couple Hall of Fame) shortstops that were available through trade or free agency precisely because Anthony Volpe was waiting in the wings. They also refused to include him in trades that would’ve bolstered last season’s playoff run. If they really think that highly of him, and since he’s spent the past month living up to that hype, he should be the starting shortstop this Thursday afternoon.

But wouldn’t it be nice if that were the only story worth talking about? Sadly, the Yankees could probably pull 72-year-old Mario Mendoza out of retirement and give him the shortstop job, and the team’s biggest concern would still be the starting rotation. Once the clear strength of the team and one of the best rotations in baseball, the Yankees’ projected starting five of Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodon, Luís Severino, Nestor Cortés, and Frankie Montas might never materialize. Rodon, Severino, and Montas will all begin the season on the IL, leaving Cole and Cortés to head a group that will also include Clarke Schmidt, Domingo Germán, and someone else. To quote a former manager, it’s not what you want.

But who knows? Maybe Aaron Judge will hit another 62 home runs, Giancarlo Stanton will play 145 games, Aaron Hicks will turn the clock back to 2018, D.J. LeMahieu will look like he did in 2020, and Josh Donaldson will prove that last season was an aberration. If all that happens, the rotation concerns won’t matter as much, will they? It’s spring, right? When else can we be so hopeful?

Categories:  1: Featured  Hank Waddles  Spring Training  Yankees

Share: Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email %PRINT_TEXT


1 Shaun P.   ~  Mar 26, 2023 4:09 pm

And meanwhile, Volpe makes the Opening Day roster, says the Athletic: https://theathletic.com/4345128/2023/03/26/anthony-volpe-opening-day-rosters-mlb-prospects/

2 Shaun P.   ~  Mar 26, 2023 4:14 pm

I am thrilled but that said, I hope that neither he nor Peraza (if he also makes it) are sitting on the bench much, because that makes no sense for their development. I also don't see where the consistent playing time comes in for both of them, barring injury or a Gleyber trade, and regardless we all know DJLM will be playing some second some of the time so... Where are all the PAs going to come from?

It's a nice "problem" to have I suppose but I have always appreciated Gleyber and it sucks that these younger kids path forward may mean the end of his path in pinstripes.

3 Shaun P.   ~  Mar 26, 2023 4:16 pm

I have just one question about the rotation - did the Yanks mess up Deivi Garcia that badly that he's not even an option for the 5th starter spot? Can't they just bring Kratz back for a couple of weeks to set him right? I don't know how things went so wrong there but sheesh.

4 rbj   ~  Mar 26, 2023 4:17 pm

Congrats to Volpe!

5 Hank Waddles   ~  Mar 26, 2023 6:52 pm

Sources tell me that Cashman and Boone read this post this morning, and that decided things in Volpe's favor.

6 Mr OK Jazz Tokyo   ~  Mar 26, 2023 9:57 pm

Thanks for the recap Hank. I've not followed anything in Spring Training so have to catch up the next few days before Opening Day. Playing the Giants is kind of weird though!

7 Ara Just Fair   ~  Mar 27, 2023 6:08 am

The injury news regarding the pitching is depressing. Good on Volpe, though. The youngest starter on Opening Day for Yanks since Jeter. Go Yankees!

8 RIYank   ~  Mar 27, 2023 7:01 pm

Starting a SS that young, no matter how talented, at shortstop??? That will never work out.
Well, there was that one time, right, it's coming back to me.

9 rbj   ~  Mar 27, 2023 7:08 pm

[8] Seattle Mariners brought an 18 y.o. kid as shortstop. I had left that city before his debut, so I never got to find out what happened to him. I think his name was Alex Rodriguez or something.

10 RIYank   ~  Mar 27, 2023 7:10 pm

[9] I mean, 'Rodriguez' is a very common name, but it does sound familiar.

11 rbj   ~  Mar 28, 2023 11:10 am

Watching the Nats-Yankees exhibition game, Nats feed. Even their announcers are already downplaying expectations for the season. Don’t expect 90 wins.

12 GaryfromChevyChase   ~  Mar 28, 2023 12:11 pm

As a Yankee fan for almost 70 years(!) and a Nats fan since they came to DC, I'm thinking that a great prop bet would be that the Yanks have the same number of wins that the Nats have losses: 97

13 Boatzilla   ~  Mar 28, 2023 8:50 pm

After the exciting WBC (Japan folks went crazy, of course), I'm not very excited about this season starting without most of our starters.

Maybe this Volpe kid will get me into things. I just hope they give him time to fail and mature.

14 cult of basebaal   ~  Mar 30, 2023 11:06 am

"The biblical rains out here in Southern California have pushed the spring so far from my mind that I only just now realized that the vernal equinox has come and gone, so how can Opening Day be only four days away?"

Hah ... you think *this* year was biblical? Just wait until you get the next ARkSTORM, like California got in the winter of 1862.

Here for Opening Day ... I even subscribed to MLB.tv so I could say I got to see Volpe's first AB.

15 RIYank   ~  Mar 30, 2023 11:12 am

It snowed here overnight. Also in New Haven, I hear. Did it snow in the Bronx?

Also just in case any of you have T-Mobile and didn't know this: you get mlb.tv for free, but you have to sign up for it in the next few days.

16 cult of basebaal   ~  Mar 30, 2023 12:10 pm


17 RIYank   ~  Mar 30, 2023 12:23 pm

Auspicious beginning!

18 RIYank   ~  Mar 30, 2023 12:55 pm

1.000 OBP career for The Fox. 5.000 on the season OPS for Judge.

feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email
"This ain't football. We do this every day."
--Earl Weaver