Is Bill James losing it? Check out this rambling essay for Slate and you tell me.
Arts and Culture
Beat of the Day
Games We Play
breaking the law
Maybe. But it's awesome anyway.
Even great players have 0-4, 3K days.
I get the gist of his argument -- that we shouldn't be hidebound to rules because that dampens down creativity. But it doesn't follow that because Babe broke some rules (such as going for home runs) that he'd break others. Babe was a Catholic, and even though he separated from his wife, he didn't get divorced -- because that went against Catholic teachings.
0) yeah, that was gobbledegook, no matter where one stands on the main issue he was discussing. I sort of tuned out once he made the vapid-verging-on-idiotic comparison between steroid use and:
Ruth knew perfectly well that he wasn't supposed to eat eight or 10 hot dogs between the games of a doubleheader, but he did it anyway.
That essay makes perfect sense to me. As usual Bill James is ahead of the curve.
I'm with Bill.
There is a difference between breaking rules (drinking or juicing) and intentionally committing perjury.
Clemens and Bonds are not "going to jail" for using steroids. They're going to jail because they lied under oath. Whether or not they belonged in those situations is another topic, but they were sworn in regardless and they intentionally lied about what they did (or so the gov't says).
Bill's argument misses that point.
 Bill's argument misses that point not at all. His point is: Let's go after the rule-breakers that are actually doing real harm to something of importance. He's saying that Clemens and Bonds should never be put in the position of being under oath, because there are much greater dangers to society to be expending energy and dollars fighting than athletes using PEDs.
Bill James is saying:
Everyone knew Babe Ruth was repeatedly breaking the laws of Prohibition. Would we have been better off if the authorities had gone after him and jailed him? He was a horrible influence on the youth of America after all.
Bill James is saying that you shouldn't eat 10 hot dogs between games of a double header and that serious crime is serious.
That was one of the worst essays I've read in a long time.
I think Congress has time for some baseball hearings. People act like they can't squeeze in some grandstanding about the national pastime between their grandstanding about other shit.
None of those ballplayers needed to show up, least of all Roger Clemens.
Old-School Banter Scroll
RHP Phil Hughes (3-5, 4.89)
LHP Hyun-Jin Ryu (6-2, 2.85)
7:05 p.m., MY9 and MLB Network
RHP Hiroki Kuroda (6-5, 2.78)
7:05 p.m., YES Network and ESPN2
Baseball Think Factory
MLB Trade Rumors
Lo Hud Yankees Blog
This Isn't Happiness
Everyday I Show